I do not like rum, so I wasn’t dying to celebrate National Hot Buttered Rum Day, but I knew that I had a couple of recipes for this cocktail and the weather was just cool enough for a hot drink to be appropriate.
So I picked up some little bottles and I made two versions.
The first is from the 2 in 1International Recipe Card Collection (1977)
Like I said, I do not like rum…
…but I do like brown sugar and butter and spices.
I liked this–the “hot rum batter” really covered up the rum. And it got me tipsy–it was sneaky because it went down so easy. I didn’t feel anything until I got up from the couch and bam!
You have been warned!
The second recipe is from one of my all-time favorite cookbooks, Benson & Hedges 100’s Presents Drink Recipes from 100 of the Greatest Bars (1979).
This recipe is nearly identical to the one in the recipe card set, but with one big difference: Dark Jamaican Rum vs. Light Rum.
What a difference the rum makes. So it turns out, that although I hate rum, I hate Jamaican Rum more. I won’t be trying this one again, but I do want to go visit the The Landmark Tavern. It’s still up and running on 11th Avenue in Manhattan! It opened in 1869 and is one of the oldest, continually-operating establishments in NYC.
I love it when the restaurants from my cookbooks are alive and well–so many have closed since publication (see: the Scandia Danish Bloody Mary (1979), , Bookbinders’ Snapper Soup (1965), and Chasen’s Chili. The list goes on).
It’s really amazing for a restaurant to survive 10 years, let alone 40+. To you, Landmark Tavern, I say, MAZEL!
Yinz remember my friend Jenny in the UK? She's the super-cool girl who runs Silver…
I don’t know what I was looking for when I pulled The New York Bartender’s…
Full disclosure: I made this dish literally one year ago. No lie. 3/11/24 is scribbled…
If you are familiar with DiS1972, you know that this little cookbook is one of…
It's National Chocolate Mint Day! At least, according to one of the many "National Day"…
How cute is the cover of this early 1960s cocktail booklet? It never really occurred…
This website uses cookies.
View Comments
I need to be in the mood for rum, but when I am, I do enjoy it. I was introduced to hot buttered rum at a dorm party where the whole thing was made in an electric kettle (the only heating appliance allowed in the dorm). Graduated to having it out of a crock pot at other parties. Definitely better with light rum.
After reading your article I was inspired to try this. Found a recipe just like the first one, with the batter and all, just cut down for one serving. It was good. Not great as I had high hopes for a nice winter toddy, but interesting. Glad I tried it as I’ve been wanting to forever since Clarence thought of ordering one in Its a Wonderful Life, lol. Thanks for the inspiration!